Skip to content

PF April 2025 topic

Resolved: The United States federal government should substantially increase its investment in domestic nuclear energy.

56 teams disclosed 165 cases on this topic on openCaselist, and Cross split them into 1,765 individual cards. The most common Pro argument was Climate; on Con it was Terror.

Pro

85 disclosed cases · 874 cards

Arguments teams ran

  • Climate5 cases
  • Fusion3 cases
  • Climate Change2 cases
  • Space2 cases

Common themes in Pro tags

  • fossil fuels
  • clean energy
  • human rights
  • perception enough
  • russia china
  • nuclear war
  • advanced nuclear
  • fast deployment

Most-read authors

Snyder (8), WNA (8), Between (5), Brook (5), Patel (5), Ahmed (4), Cassella (4), Conca (4), Graham (4), Lee (4)

Example cards

  • SMRs solve traditional concerns – costs, scalability, safety

    Brandon Rakszawski, 11 · Climate · Read the card

  • And, decarbonization efforts are coming now, but current strategy lacks diversification – only increased investment solves

    Ejeong Baik et al. 21 · Climate · Read the card

  • The root cause of colonialism is the desire for energy growth --- fossil fuel extraction in Africa proves AND the shift towards renewables is just a colonial guise to mask the shifting of unsustainable colonial relations

    Basak and Wakounig 24 · Fusion · Read the card

  • Fusion is on the brink of feasibility

    Potter 24 · Fusion · Read the card

  • Emissions are set to spiral.

    Copely 25 · Climate Change · Read the card

  • Alternatively,

    Snyder 23 · Climate Change · Read the card

Con

80 disclosed cases · 891 cards

Arguments teams ran

  • Terror8 cases
  • Poland3 cases
  • Tradeoff3 cases
  • Accidents2 cases
  • Russia2 cases
  • UUVs2 cases

Common themes in Con tags

  • nuclear reactors
  • trades off
  • oil demand
  • increased supply
  • supply lowers
  • prices decks
  • decks russia
  • oil prices

Most-read authors

Jacobson (8), Clare (6), Cooper (6), Baltvilks (5), Between (5), Macfarlane (5), Smith (5), CAN (4), Johnson (4), Portuondo (4)

Example cards

  • New reactors require HALEU.

    Robinson 24 · Terror · Read the card

  • But a lack of funding is preventing implementation.

    Geiger 25 · Terror · Read the card

  • Nuclear exports are low.

    Park ’23 · Poland · Read the card

  • Aff causes nuclearization – the US would actively sell SMRs to nuclear-seeking states.

    Green, '19 · Poland · Read the card

  • The renewable market is thriving

    DiGangi 25 · Tradeoff · Read the card

  • Substantial investment in nuclear energy would trade off with renewables

    Hockenos 22 · Tradeoff · Read the card

Counts are disclosed cases (one team's case at one tournament), not cards, so one long case can't skew them. Themes are phrases that show up far more in one side's card tags than the other's, counted per team. Teams aren't named on public pages. Cards are as the teams disclosed them; check the original source before reading one in a round.

Other topics