Skip to content

PF September–October 2026 topic

548 teams disclosed 2252 cases on this topic on openCaselist, and Cross split them into 11,285 individual cards. The most common Pro argument was Grids; on Con it was Economy.

Pro

1096 disclosed cases · 5,393 cards

Arguments teams ran

  • Grids29 cases
  • Climate16 cases
  • Water16 cases
  • AGI13 cases
  • Environment11 cases
  • False Profits10 cases
  • Solvency9 cases
  • Agriculture8 cases

Common themes in Pro tags

  • fossil fuels
  • grid collapse
  • public health
  • electricity demand
  • natural gas
  • centers being
  • moratorium allows
  • center electricity

Most-read authors

Sanders (33), Rogan (20), Kyc (18), Yousuf (16), Clare (15), Greenfield (15), Brands (14), Congress (14), Sussman (14), IEA (13)

Example cards

  • Data centers require tons of electricity.

    Stover 24 · Grids · Read the card

  • Data centers spike utilities

    Ph. D. Brannon 24 · Grids · Read the card

  • A moratorium is key---the next few years are exponentially worse.

    Howland 26 · Climate · Read the card

  • A single facility will draw three times the electricity of New Orleans.

    Sanders 26 · Climate · Read the card

  • Data centers are water guzzlers, inducing a crisis --- the AFF solves reverse-causally

    Kaur ’25 · Water · Read the card

  • Water scarcity goes nuclear.

    Mohsin et al. ’25 · Water · Read the card

Con

1156 disclosed cases · 5,892 cards

Arguments teams ran

  • Economy36 cases
  • Econ33 cases
  • Offshoring32 cases
  • Midterms21 cases
  • Innovation14 cases
  • AI race12 cases
  • Federalism12 cases
  • China11 cases

Common themes in Con tags

  • nuclear war
  • first strike
  • united states
  • investor confidence
  • economic growth
  • losing race
  • economic decline
  • water use

Most-read authors

Phillips-Robins (25), Allen (20), Kimball (20), Barnes (17), Reuters (17), Huddleston (15), Williams (15), Edwards (14), Lichtenberg (14), Smith (14)

Example cards

  • [DL] Grid operators utilize demand-response programs to maintain stability during peak loads.

    Reuters 26 · Economy · Read the card

  • T] Data centers lower electricity bills—empirics prove.

    Hedger 07 · Economy · Read the card

  • AI capital expenditures accounted for 1/3rd of US GDP growth

    Edwards 26 · Econ · Read the card

  • State litigation is preserving federalism.

    Shorman 26 · Econ · Read the card

  • Ireland established a moratorium on data center construction in 2023.

    Webber '26 · Offshoring · Read the card

  • Mexico has intentionally stripped regulations, hurting the most vulnerable.

    Baptista ’25 · Offshoring · Read the card

Counts are disclosed cases (one team's case at one tournament), not cards, so one long case can't skew them. Themes are phrases that show up far more in one side's card tags than the other's, counted per team. Teams aren't named on public pages. Cards are as the teams disclosed them; check the original source before reading one in a round.

Other topics