Skip to content

PF January 2026 topic

Resolved: The People's Republic of China should substantially reduce its international extraction of natural resources.

55 teams disclosed 173 cases on this topic on openCaselist, and Cross split them into 1,473 individual cards. The most common Pro argument was Arctic; on Con it was Environment.

Pro

90 disclosed cases · 714 cards

Arguments teams ran

  • Arctic4 cases
  • Fishing4 cases
  • Afghanistan2 cases
  • Climate Change2 cases
  • Moon2 cases
  • Myanmar2 cases
  • Oil2 cases
  • Pakistan2 cases

Common themes in Pro tags

  • resource extraction
  • chinese mining
  • chinese extraction
  • china mining
  • resource disputes
  • water contamination
  • air pollution
  • companies fail

Most-read authors

Risi (8), Chen (6), Lisinski (6), ADF (5), Asante (5), Lee (5), Matabaro (5), Chiu (4), Klinger (4), Reuters (4)

Example cards

  • Conflict over the Senkaku Islands is escalating and draws in the US.

    Nippon 12 · Arctic · Read the card

  • Chinese natural resource extraction forces invasion of the Senkaku Islands.

    Lee 25 · Arctic · Read the card

  • Otherwise, conflict triggers draw-in.

    Joe Varner 25 · Fishing · Read the card

  • And Sustainable fishing solves nuclear winter.

    Scherrer 20 · Fishing · Read the card

  • China dominates Afghan resource extraction, fueling terrorism that escalates regional instability. The aff is key to undercut funding.

    Dawar 25 · Afghanistan · Read the card

  • Otherwise, terrorism is the root cause of Afghanistan-Pakistan instability, posing an existential threat.

    Ducharme 25 · Afghanistan · Read the card

Con

83 disclosed cases · 759 cards

Arguments teams ran

  • Environment3 cases
  • Lashout3 cases
  • AI Bubble2 cases
  • Green Tech2 cases
  • North Korea2 cases
  • Race to the Top OV2 cases
  • Rosatom2 cases
  • Russia2 cases

Common themes in Con tags

  • international extraction
  • mineral extraction
  • nuclear war
  • china complies
  • complies top
  • top international
  • extraction standards
  • standards shapes

Most-read authors

Cocodia (6), Mann (5), Zhiyenbayev (5), Asante (4), Butts (4), Cassella (4), Lang (4), Nero Huang (4), Zadeh (4), Appiah-Otoo et al. (3)

Example cards

  • T - China is making progress on improving environmental standards.

    DiCarlo ’24 · Environment · Read the card

  • [T] The benefits of resource extraction for the environment outweighs the harms, evidenced by history

    Xu 24 · Environment · Read the card

  • Military power is inextricably tied to minerals.

    Dr. Morgan Bazilian & Gregory Wischer 24 · Lashout · Read the card

  • China’s status is upheld by mineral production, but international extraction is key.

    Dr. Morgan Bazilian & Gregory Wischer 24 · Lashout · Read the card

  • The AI Bubble won’t pop, but reversing expectations causes immediate collapse. Prefer expert consensus.

    Dr. Sohail Rao 25 · AI Bubble · Read the card

  • REMs are essential to AI. Decreasing supply pops the bubble.

    Gennaro Cuofano 25 · AI Bubble · Read the card

Counts are disclosed cases (one team's case at one tournament), not cards, so one long case can't skew them. Themes are phrases that show up far more in one side's card tags than the other's, counted per team. Teams aren't named on public pages. Cards are as the teams disclosed them; check the original source before reading one in a round.

Other topics