Skip to content

PF February 2025 topic

Resolved: The United States should accede to the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court.

49 teams disclosed 147 cases on this topic on openCaselist, and Cross split them into 1,103 individual cards. The most common Pro argument was Sanctions; on Con it was Israel.

Pro

73 disclosed cases · 533 cards

Arguments teams ran

  • Sanctions4 cases
  • Deportations2 cases
  • Food Aid2 cases
  • Iron Man2 cases

Common themes in Pro tags

  • icc has
  • war crimes
  • soft power
  • joining icc
  • lack funding
  • has potential
  • great powers
  • absent action

Most-read authors

Article (10), Scheffer (10), Ford (8), Vindman (8), Alberstadt (4), Hortnagl (4), Kuo (4), Perry (4), Roth (4), Sadat (4)

Example cards

  • Trump just passed sanctions through an executive order.

    Edwards 25 · Sanctions · Read the card

  • That’s devastating as the survival of the court is key for the prevention and prosecution of heinous crimes

    Ford 20 · Sanctions · Read the card

  • Deportations collapse the economy.

    AIC 24 · Deportations · Read the card

  • Affirming holds developers liable for unjustified aggression.

    Hassan 23 · Deportations · Read the card

  • Fortunately, recognition allows Somaliland to receive adaptation funds.

    Musse ’24 · Food Aid · Read the card

  • Historically, these organizations have been effective at increasing agriculture and livestock.

    Alemayehu 24 · Food Aid · Read the card

Con

74 disclosed cases · 570 cards

Arguments teams ran

  • Israel8 cases
  • Drones5 cases
  • ) Counter Terror3 cases

Common themes in Con tags

  • arrest warrants
  • power projection
  • safe havens
  • military action
  • forces invasion
  • kalshoven zegveld
  • prolongs conflict
  • peace agreement

Most-read authors

Groves (9), Alberstadt (5), Article (5), Balachandran (5), Casey (5), Wheeler (5), Brands (4), Brown (4), Dunlap (4), Duursma (4)

Example cards

  • That’s key

    Freilich 17 · Israel · Read the card

  • Current support quells conflict in the region.

    Shinego 25 · Israel · Read the card

  • Independently, terrorism causes mass death

    Africa Center For Strategic Studies 24 · Drones · Read the card

  • Drones are key to disrupt safe havens.

    Mitt Regan 22 · Drones · Read the card

  • US counter terror efforts are increasing but rely on drone strikes

    Rollins 23 · ) Counter Terror · Read the card

  • But, Rome bans drone strikes against non-state actors.

    Alberstadt ’14 · ) Counter Terror · Read the card

Counts are disclosed cases (one team's case at one tournament), not cards, so one long case can't skew them. Themes are phrases that show up far more in one side's card tags than the other's, counted per team. Teams aren't named on public pages. Cards are as the teams disclosed them; check the original source before reading one in a round.

Other topics