Skip to content

PF January 2025 topic

Resolved: The African Union should grant diplomatic recognition to the Republic of Somaliland as an independent state.

52 teams disclosed 175 cases on this topic on openCaselist, and Cross split them into 1,323 individual cards. The most common Pro argument was Piracy; on Con it was Civil War.

Pro

89 disclosed cases · 655 cards

Arguments teams ran

  • Piracy7 cases
  • Democracy3 cases
  • Economy3 cases
  • Overfishing3 cases
  • Regional stability3 cases
  • China War2 cases
  • Food Aid2 cases
  • Governance2 cases

Common themes in Pro tags

  • climate change
  • conflict inevitable
  • horn africa
  • although food
  • war inevitable
  • recognize somaliland
  • absent action
  • rem shortage

Most-read authors

Schwartz (16), Idaan (14), Meservey (11), Robinson (6), Rubin (6), Webb (6), Clapham (5), Economist (5), Ali (4), Beaubien (4)

Example cards

  • It’s raising shipping costs and will exceed previous levels.

    Paravicini 24 · Piracy · Read the card

  • Indeed,

    Walker 11 · Piracy · Read the card

  • Democracies are key to solving climate change – civil checks and changing societal consensus

    Casas-Zamora 21 · Democracy · Read the card

  • Africa is key --- it’s urbanizing and a rapidly growing population.

    Goldstone 21 · Democracy · Read the card

  • Affirming clarifies jurisdiction and cooperation --- the AU has the legitimacy.

    Schwartz 21 · Overfishing · Read the card

  • AND leads to pandemics.

    Khan 15 · Overfishing · Read the card

Con

86 disclosed cases · 668 cards

Arguments teams ran

  • Civil War3 cases
  • Invasion3 cases
  • Secession3 cases
  • Terror3 cases
  • AT: Piracy2 cases
  • Instability2 cases
  • Piracy2 cases

Common themes in Con tags

  • civil war
  • secessionist movements
  • somalia has
  • somaliland civil
  • economic growth
  • ethiopia somalia
  • recognition somaliland
  • war devastating

Most-read authors

Hassan (14), Mahmood (12), Idaan (10), Said (9), Horton (7), Webb (7), Batten (6), Dua (5), Elmi (5), Ayele (4)

Example cards

  • Tensions in Somaliland are capped.

    Hiiraan 24 · Civil War · Read the card

  • Despite tensions, escalation isn’t imminent.

    Kurtz 24 · Invasion · Read the card

  • Independently, affirming spurs Chinese involvement which causes war.

    Hagi 24 · Invasion · Read the card

  • Currently, trust in the Somaliland government is fragile but recovering.

    Mahmood 24 · Secession · Read the card

  • It’s declining.

    Nyaboga Kiage 11 · Terror · Read the card

  • That’s an impact filter—

    Stephen Clare, 80 · Terror · Read the card

Counts are disclosed cases (one team's case at one tournament), not cards, so one long case can't skew them. Themes are phrases that show up far more in one side's card tags than the other's, counted per team. Teams aren't named on public pages. Cards are as the teams disclosed them; check the original source before reading one in a round.

Other topics