Skip to content

PF November–December 2025 topic

Resolved: The United States federal government should require technology companies to provide lawful access to encrypted communications.

50 teams disclosed 158 cases on this topic on openCaselist, and Cross split them into 1,306 individual cards. The most common Pro argument was Cartels; on Con it was Politics.

Pro

81 disclosed cases · 733 cards

Arguments teams ran

  • Cartels3 cases
  • ECON3 cases
  • Courts2 cases
  • Green Tech2 cases
  • Investment2 cases
  • Russia2 cases
  • Terror2 cases

Common themes in Pro tags

  • encrypted communications
  • law enforcement
  • human trafficking
  • tipping points
  • goes nuclear
  • legally binding
  • gold bubble
  • china has

Most-read authors

Corn (5), Manpearl (4), Coffey (3), Corbett (3), Drenik (3), Eric Manpearl (3), Graham (3), NCSR (3), Robert Haddick (3), Walker (3)

Example cards

  • Cartels up NOW

    Ledo 25 · Cartels · Read the card

  • And, human trafficking is increasing because of encryption.

    Mary Nikkel, 24 · Cartels · Read the card

  • Indeed,

    Swati Dhingra 16 · ECON · Read the card

  • This can be attributed to the UK experiencing greater barriers to trade post brexit

    Ward 25 · ECON · Read the card

  • Courts are overstretched now.

    USCourts 25 · Courts · Read the card

  • Access to encrypted evidence speeds up cases.

    Herman et al 20 · Courts · Read the card

Con

77 disclosed cases · 573 cards

Arguments teams ran

  • Politics5 cases
  • Democracy3 cases
  • Economy v22 cases
  • Escalation2 cases
  • Nuclear Energy2 cases
  • Space2 cases
  • Stocks2 cases

Common themes in Con tags

  • weakening encryption
  • million people
  • climate change
  • energy production
  • defensive spikes
  • recession goes
  • renewable energy
  • role ballot

Most-read authors

Gladwin (7), Mortimer (5), Eoyang (4), Mueller (3), Pfefferkorn (3), Weichert (3), West (3), Anwais Rashid (2), Ariel Cohen (2), Article (2)

Example cards

  • Declining legitimacy causes lashout and invasion

    Blumenthal 20 · Politics · Read the card

  • Xi’s regime is stable. Cunningham 25

    Cunningham 25 · Politics · Read the card

  • Democracy may bend but won’t break under current threats.

    Beauchamp 10 · Democracy · Read the card

  • That gets modeled

    Kang 22 · Democracy · Read the card

  • The economy is resilient---tech is key

    Larry Adam, 11 · Economy v2 · Read the card

  • Backdoors deck the economy---expert consensus.

    Joel Gladwin and Colin Mortimer 24 · Economy v2 · Read the card

Counts are disclosed cases (one team's case at one tournament), not cards, so one long case can't skew them. Themes are phrases that show up far more in one side's card tags than the other's, counted per team. Teams aren't named on public pages. Cards are as the teams disclosed them; check the original source before reading one in a round.

Other topics