Skip to content

PF November–December 2024 topic

Resolved: The United States should substantially reduce its military support of Taiwan.

58 teams disclosed 174 cases on this topic on openCaselist, and Cross split them into 1,364 individual cards. The most common Pro argument was Escalation; on Con it was China.

Pro

92 disclosed cases · 660 cards

Arguments teams ran

  • Escalation6 cases
  • Accidents3 cases
  • Relations3 cases
  • ) Arms2 cases
  • Democracy2 cases
  • Grey Zones2 cases
  • Ukraine2 cases

Common themes in Pro tags

  • arms race
  • support taiwan
  • noko nuclear
  • pacific region
  • taiwan china
  • war china
  • great power
  • taiwan arms

Most-read authors

Glaser (7), Swaine (7), DOA (6), Gomez (6), Brands (5), Bruce Gilley (4), Chen (4), Eric Gomez (4), Kim (4), Sulmaan Wasif Khan (4)

Example cards

  • Military support shifts voters to resist China.

    Chen 24 · Escalation · Read the card

  • Hence, invasion comes by 2025.

    Mollman 23 · Escalation · Read the card

  • Taipei can’t do it alone --- they’re reliant on the US.

    Dnyuz 24 · Accidents · Read the card

  • 50 nukes are existential.

    Cribb 19 · Accidents · Read the card

  • China despises support

    Abraham 24 · Relations · Read the card

  • US military support to Taiwan exacerbates tensions.

    Hao Nan, 09 · Relations · Read the card

Con

82 disclosed cases · 704 cards

Arguments teams ran

  • China4 cases
  • Deterrence3 cases
  • India3 cases
  • Alliances2 cases
  • Ally Proliferation2 cases
  • Economy2 cases
  • Israel2 cases
  • Terror2 cases

Common themes in Con tags

  • nuclear war
  • abandoning taiwan
  • strike capabilities
  • goes nuclear
  • undocumented immigrants
  • cyber attacks
  • climate change
  • tsmc boom

Most-read authors

Cunningham (9), Kelly C. Wadsworth (6), Anna Ribeiro (5), Talmadge (5), Barrons (4), Christopher Bing and Karen Freifeld (4), Henley (4), Rubin (4), Studeman (4), Adam Lowther, (3)

Example cards

  • Xi’s economic strategy points to war

    Studeman 24 · China · Read the card

  • Otherwise war as U.S. gets drawn in

    Talmadge 18 · China · Read the card

  • Every sign points to Xi desiring reunification now

    Studeman 24 · Deterrence · Read the card

  • Reunification hands Xi the political stability he needs

    Studeman 24 · Deterrence · Read the card

  • Tensions are down now.

    Scobell 10 · India · Read the card

  • Affirming causes invasion.

    Gokhale 23 · India · Read the card

Counts are disclosed cases (one team's case at one tournament), not cards, so one long case can't skew them. Themes are phrases that show up far more in one side's card tags than the other's, counted per team. Teams aren't named on public pages. Cards are as the teams disclosed them; check the original source before reading one in a round.

Other topics