Skip to content

PF September–October 2024 topic

Resolved: The United States federal government should substantially expand its surveillance infrastructure along its southern border.

60 teams disclosed 191 cases on this topic on openCaselist, and Cross split them into 1,475 individual cards. The most common Pro argument was Cartels; on Con it was Agriculture.

Pro

97 disclosed cases · 776 cards

Arguments teams ran

  • Cartels3 cases
  • Drugs3 cases
  • Pandemics3 cases
  • Disease2 cases
  • Politics2 cases
  • Taiwan2 cases
  • Trade2 cases
  • Trucking2 cases

Common themes in Pro tags

  • southern border
  • human trafficking
  • latin america
  • mexico border
  • border security
  • absent action
  • border crisis
  • trafficking victims

Most-read authors

Strickler (8), Starr (6), DHS (5), Kim (5), CBP (4), CDC (4), Christian Penichet-Paul, (4), Davis (4), Esposito (4), Krepinevich & Lindsey (4)

Example cards

  • Because of the US’ lax gun laws,

    Lowy & Moreno 23 · Cartels · Read the card

  • Empirically,

    Stephens 24 · Cartels · Read the card

  • Stimming the crisis is imperative.

    Ovalle 24 · Drugs · Read the card

  • This is allowed due to a lack of surveillance.

    Strickler 24 · Drugs · Read the card

  • Next Pandemic Likely to Originate from Mexico

    Horrox 20 · Pandemics · Read the card

  • Pandemics cause extinction

    Pamlin and Armstrong 15 · Pandemics · Read the card

Con

94 disclosed cases · 699 cards

Arguments teams ran

  • Agriculture3 cases
  • Economy3 cases
  • Relations3 cases
  • Democracy2 cases
  • Tradeoff2 cases

Common themes in Con tags

  • undocumented immigrants
  • cyber security
  • nuke war
  • dangerous routes
  • indeed dhs
  • dhs confirms
  • trades off
  • states massey

Most-read authors

Guerrero (9), DHS, (6), Greer (5), Miller (5), Katz (4), Parrish (4), Tyler (4), Alden (3), Beaumont (3), Biddle (3)

Example cards

  • Global food exports are reliant on the US.

    Reinsch 23 · Agriculture · Read the card

  • A continued flow is key.

    Sims 21 · Agriculture · Read the card

  • Econ is up - Holistic analysis agrees

    Gibbard 24 · Economy · Read the card

  • Price Shocks Kill Millions

    Alexander 22 · Economy · Read the card

  • Relations are growing but any disagreement has the potential to kill them – the brink is now.

    Mahoney 24 · Relations · Read the card

  • Sheinbaum will disagree with border surveillance to protect her voter base – that kills relations.

    Shaw 24 · Relations · Read the card

Counts are disclosed cases (one team's case at one tournament), not cards, so one long case can't skew them. Themes are phrases that show up far more in one side's card tags than the other's, counted per team. Teams aren't named on public pages. Cards are as the teams disclosed them; check the original source before reading one in a round.

Other topics